Forums

Homosexual men and women - one from Jupiter the other Pluto?

Page:   1 2 3
 
 

Sandy
 
Joined in 2007
June 24, 2007, 20:53

I agree with your comments about feminism Sue. The amount of times I have heard bad or dirty jokes about Germaine Greer or Betty Friedrian amoung gay men is ridiclous. Which is not to mention that most ‘modern day’ feminists raise an eyebrow at some of the things Greer says anyway! Just a note to all the guys out there, feminists are fighting for exactly what you all are, reciognition for a minority group to be accepted and given equal rights as the rest of society.


Maybe as far as F2B goes it may be a good idea to have a seperate meeting for women and to promote it as an all woman thing, having been abused by men myself if I walk into a room full of men and am asked to participate with them and perhaps bare my soul, there is no way in the world I’d do it.



magsdee
Disabled
Joined in 2006
June 24, 2007, 21:32

Great point Sandy, sadly too many women have been abused by men and it all boils down to a trust and a feeling safe issue. A womens group sounds good to me for those who would feel better having one.


The one thing I loved about what my niece told me about living waters was how the men stand on one side of the room and the women on the other and how they put the cross between the two, then the two sides meet in the middle and a healing process begins, it doesnt mean you will suddenly be straight from it all, it just means the hurt and pain from either side has a chance to be healed…..I think the guys apologise to the women that they hurt them as a gender and vice versa, they either hug or shake hands or do whatever they feel comfortable doing and God does the rest…..my niece has never looked back. The seminar went for a week.



Sandy
 
Joined in 2007
July 6, 2008, 00:04

I was going to start a new thread but then found this gem tucked away back here and the subject line is punchier than anything I could come up with… so thankyou Anthony.


I was so excited when I heard this that I actually squealed… in front of actual people 😳 😆


Anyway, UC San Deigo is conducting a study on the behavioural and social-psychologial differences between gay males and lesbains. Even better, I actually know the people conducting the study! I mentioned this site to one of them and they asked me if I could ‘ask around’ and see what people thought on the issue. There is a fancy way of explaining all this but basically when studying observable behaviour to check the validity of any findings we need to make sure that they are actually what we say they are i.e. observable behaviours in an everyday context and we are not just reading too much into things or stereotyping.


So, after that long winded introduction I am just looking for your comments. What are the differences between gay men and lesbians (besides the obvious attraction issue)? How are these differences played out? Does gender identity play a role? etc etc etc. Pretty much just go wild 😆


Thanks!



magsdee
Disabled
Joined in 2006
July 6, 2008, 09:09

Far out, this is an oldie ressurected 😀 cool, will have to think on this one 8)



Anthony Venn-Brown
 
Joined in 2005
July 6, 2008, 10:53

great….I find this stuff fascinating. Glad there is research on it.


I’ve got lots of assumptions…..some will be true others only perceived I’m sure.


Is there some formula you’d like us to post in Sandy for consistency.



Sandy
 
Joined in 2007
July 6, 2008, 16:48

Not really… Im not apart of the research team (I promised myself I’d never make homosexuality my career) and I just thought I would lend the people who are doing it a hand because I have ‘contacts’ 😆 and because I can’t leave well enough alone.


Assumptions are good if you can back them up with your experiences. We are looking for observable behaviours in everday life so if you were to say that, for example, gay men are more prone towards squealing in church (those responsible will remain nameless of course 😆 ) than lesbians I need to know why you assume this. The documentation on this kind of validity test is always extreemly light, its just a safegaurd again reseracher bias basically. None of it goes into the actual paper and doesn’t influence the findings in any way.


So… thats a long winded way of saying as long as you explain your assumptions you can format it anyway you’d like. I may edit a few things (personal comments, repitition) before I hand it over to my friends but that is no drama. I thought it would be fun to talk about and I thought Anthony you would jump at the chance since this is Sandy asking avb for his subjective experinces! Miracles do happen. 😆 😆


Also, the study is fighting against a myriad of other studies for funding from the university to go ahead, so there is a good chance it may never get beyond the theoretical stages. The more likley the study is to be accurate and make some kind of substantial contribution the better the chances of getting funds… so validity is crucial.



Anthony Venn-Brown
 
Joined in 2005
July 6, 2008, 22:46

I find it a fascinating topic as i guess for the first time since I came out I have to consider thoughtfully how I communicate with, relate to and engage my homosexual sisters. Freedom 2 b[e] has forced me to do that.


For the first 14 years as an out man I’ve never really had to think about any of these things. I lived in my predominantly gay mans world and usually the only conversations i had with lesbians was at some dance party or recovery in the early hours of the morning. at that time and state I guess i could have carried on a conversation with anyone. Just can’t remember them. 😆


Anyway……wanting to create this space at F2B means its for GLBTI…..so that means I have to learn to be inclusive.


I naively thought…….just put on a meeting and they will come. Well they did……minus the women. Our chapter meetings are at this stage predominately male. what was wrong I thought. In our churches….we were all brothers and sisters……surely it should be the same.


When it didn’t I had to search. that search has definitely made me more lesbian sensitive and aware…….thanks some intense conversations with some lesbians who let me know how my male gay centric thinking was far removed from theirs. I’m willing to learn.


Maybe we dont need to be together. Maybe our cultures and socialism are so far removed from each other it will never work.


these are some of the questions that go through my mind.


I have been thrilled to see the engagement here on the forum though…..for some reason our differences don’t seem as big here.


…..and of course everytime some of the women/ladies/girls (i think i even have to be careful which word I use their) showed up at our meetings….they were welcomed with a welcome no one else has ever received.



Sandy
 
Joined in 2007
July 7, 2008, 10:26

Thanks for that Anthony.


I think its my fate to always have gay men in my life and I’ll admitt that it is often a challenge. Different things tend to hold more value than others and I have often be caught saying “for goodness sake, why does that even matter?!” about something that holds alot of importnace to my father in particular. Combine the ‘gay factor’ with the usual father/daughter relationship and you have a recipie for both disaster and intense love.


I find it so interesting because its all so diverse. Its unwise to assume that ‘lesbians will act this way’ and ‘gay men will act this way’. Within the lesbian community there is still the distinction between butch and femme though the obvious role characterisation is not as socially acceptable or necessary these days. Still, I think the butch/femme dicotomy has some validity still in the personal realm, power is still often divided that way as it is in heterosexual relationships. So what drives a ‘butch lesbian’ with a more masculine gender identity is different to what drives a ‘femme lesbian’ with a feminine gender identity. In alot of cases it’s the beginning of a great relationship but not always compete understanding of each other.


So the does the distinction the have to be made between butch, femme and gay male in order for this study to sucessed? What about distinctions between men?


Gay and lesbian activities with the obvious exception of the Mardi Gras are usually seperate anyway. I don’t know much about the way F2b is structured but I would find walking into a room full of gay men intimidating esepically if the idea is to get emotionally intimate about personal aspects of your lives. Actually, reading a comment Maggie made previously about the lack of lesbian only social events I think that what she said gets truer and truer every year. The internet has taken over the lesbian community, esepically in terms of dating. There is less initial face to face interaction and less of a casual air to any club scene that does exist. I wince when people try and sterotype lesbians as all looking for their soulmate and pretty much sexless until they get there. Probably in the same way people wince about homosexual promiscuity but I think their is a great differnece in socialisation between gay men and lesbians.



Anthony Venn-Brown
 
Joined in 2005
July 7, 2008, 14:08

I think we can safely generalise in some aspects but of course it is not stereo typical.


For example

we could generalise that gay men tend to want to party more than lesbians


we could safely generalise that lesbians are more relationship oriented than gay men.


we could generalise that gay men are more obsessed with sex than lesbians.


we could generalise that gay men are more femine and and lesbians more masculine than our heterosexual genders counterparts.


my observations only of course…….and not everyone fits these catagories.



Sandy
 
Joined in 2007
July 7, 2008, 19:46

You are always so much more susinct than I am! 😆 Forgive my ramblings. Thanks for your thoughts, anyone else have any comments?


I could go on all day but surprisingly Im never half as facinating to other people as I think I am… no idea why 😆 😆


Page:   1 2 3
 
WP Forum Server by ForumPress | LucidCrew
Version: 99.9; Page loaded in: 0.073 seconds.